Our
Summary Of This Fad Diet
Similar
to Mastering the Zone and Dr. Atkins New Diet Revolution, the Sugar
Busters diet claims that carbohydrate (sugar) causes obesity and insulin
resistance in the United States. The authors advocate the elimination
of carbohydrate from the diet, claiming that one will not overeat
foods high in sugar and become insulin resistant. Again, by removing
carbohydrate and sugar from the diet, a significant number of calories
are eliminated, creating a caloric deficit and, thus, weight loss.
An analysis performed by the American Dietetic Association indicates
that the menu plans recommended in the book yield approximately 1,200
calories a day. It is not the lack of carbohydrates that cause one
to lose weight but rather the very low calorie intake.
Advantages:
The authors recommend consuming lean cuts of meat in addition to fruits
and vegetables. Regular exercise is also encouraged.
Disadvantages:
Similar to other high-protein plans, rebound is inevitable due to
eventual carbohydrate cravings and the unrealistic restrictions proposed
by the diet.
The
deception here is brilliant because an increase in body fat can lead
to insulin resistance (IR). Therefore, lowering body fat with any
method can reverse IR.
They
make you believe that your carbohydrate intake (not weight gain) leads
to the IR and that starts the increase in body fat. By removing carbohydrates,
the calories decline, and succinctly body weight, leading to a reversal
of IR. The authors win because you lost weight and became insulin
sensitive again, but you lose because once you grow tired of protein
and are starved for carbohydrates, you will rebound with a vengeance.**
The
American Dietetic Association analyzed the recipes recommended by
the book and found that each menu averaged a mere 1,200 calories a
day. This is an unrealistic restriction on food intake that cannot
be maintained. Keep in mind that weight loss itself reduces
the disease symptoms of obesity; not necessarily the method in which
one achieves it.
Long-term
success:
Due to inevitable carbohydrate cravings, long-range success is unlikely.
**The
bottom line is that this food plan is not the best way to lower your
food intake unless you are strictly throwing out junk food. You must
maintain a healthy balance of good carbohydrates within a caloric
allotment that promotes a healthy and desired level of body fat.
Sugar
Busters diet was created by: H. Leighton Steward, Morrison C. Bethea,
M.D., Sam S. Andrews, M.D., Ralph O. Brennan and Luis A. Balart, M.D.